• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sweet Creams Cafe: Delicious Ice Cream, Sandwiches & Friendly Service in Stroudsburg

Sweet Creams Cafe in Stroudsburg, PA, is a welcoming spot known for generous sandwiches and indulgent homemade ice cream treats. Diners rave about their flavorful sandwiches—with highlights like crispy bacon and tender chicken—and crave their signature sundaes, including warm brownie sundaes and classic banana splits. The attentive, friendly service adds to the inviting atmosphere, even during busy or challenging moments. Their creative drinks like basil lemonade complement the diverse menu perfectly. Sweet Creams Cafe stands out as a local gem where quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation create memorable meals and desserts worth revisiting time and again.

Sweet Creams Cafe at a glance

  • Address 429 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, United States
  • Phone (570) 421-7929
  • Restaurant type Cafe , American restaurant , Coffee shop , Ice cream shop , Sandwich shop .
  • Popular for Lunch , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Sweet Creams Cafe: Reviews & Ratings

Tho Nguyen
5

Generous sandwich portions, awesome sundaes, and amazing customer service! The picture isn’t great, but this sundae was one of the best banana splits I’ve had in a while. They even customized it for us, which was so nice! The sandwiches were pretty good, but wish it was toasted/served warm. We were there for their “trial dine in”, so full seating is still not available, and didn’t seem like they had full serving staff, but our waitress was extremely friendly and accommodating! Would definitely come back to try their other desserts

Victoria Pnacek
5

Ordered potato wedges, nachos, egg salad and bacon sandwich, Tuscany ciabatta sandwich. Absolutely AMAZING!! So flavorful. Bacon was crispy and fresh. Chicken breast was tender and sun dried tomato spread was perfect.

Tara Ignatovich
5

Customer service was attentive and pleasant. Food was out quick and was phenomenal. Dessert was the absolute best part, and I am willing to drive an hour away again for another 'homemade brownie sundae'. I got mine with chocolate ice cream and hot fudge. The brownie was warm and delicious. Highly recommend.

Rob Orr
5

We have been going to this ice cream shop since the pandemic- their ice cream is terrific! We wanted to celebrate National Ice Cream Day today and this was the perfect place to do so!

David W Coulter
5

Had a terrific sandwich today with a soothing double scoop of chocolate mint ice cream as a chaser. Excellent. Had lunch again at Sweet Creams today and even as the power went out they continued their service. We the Smokey Mountain, smoked turkey sandwich and the California BLT. Terrific! Also, had the basil lemonade and an Arnold Palmer. Loved that basil lemonade! 5 more stars!

Reema Mulchandani
5

I had an incredible experience at Sweet Cream Cafe! From the moment I walked in, I was welcomed with a warm smile and the most amazing hospitality. I decided to try the Brownie Sundae with vanilla ice cream and hot fudge, and it was pure bliss—instantly took me to my happy place! The cozy interiors added to the charm, making it the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a sweet treat. Overall, I really enjoyed my time here and would highly recommend this cafe to anyone looking for great service and delicious desserts!

Location

  • Sweet Creams Cafe
    Sweet Creams Cafe
    429 Main St, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, United States Hotline: (570) 421-7929

Sweet Creams Cafe, nestled in the heart of Stroudsburg, PA, is a cozy haven for those who appreciate thoughtfully crafted café fare alongside decadent desserts. Located at 429 Main St, this spot delivers generous portions and a menu that effortlessly balances comfort and creativity. From flaky croissants and fresh, vibrant salads like the Chicken Caesar to inventive sandwiches such as the Pesto Chicken and Mediterranean Hummus, each dish showcases a careful blend of quality ingredients and classic flavors.

The cafe’s dessert selection truly stands out, highlighted by customer favorites like the Banana Split and the Mounds Ice Cream Sundae. Reports of warm, homemade brownie sundaes paired with rich hot fudge and chocolate ice cream create an irresistible allure. The Salted Caramel Ice Cream Sandwich also earns notable praise for its perfect sweet-salty harmony. Ice cream lovers will find joy in every scoop, as loyal patrons have returned time and again to celebrate the shop's exceptional frozen treats.

Beverages are equally compelling, with inventive choices like Basil Lemonade and Berry Hibiscus Iced Tea redefining traditional refreshment. The Arnold Palmer and a variety of organic teas provide a layered tasting experience, complementing both savory and sweet offerings. Notably, the Basil Lemonade has garnered enthusiastic acclaim, adding a fresh, herbaceous twist that brightens the palate.

Customer service at Sweet Creams Cafe impresses with its warmth and attentiveness, creating a welcoming atmosphere even during transitional phases like limited seating. The staff's willingness to customize orders and accommodate diners enhances the overall experience, making every visit memorable.

Sweet Creams Cafe is not just about satisfying hunger but about relishing each bite, whether it's the crispy, flavorful bacon in a Tuscany ciabatta sandwich or the comforting warmth of Italian Wedding Soup. The Veggie & 3 Cheese Pizza Combo offers a delightful medley of textures and tastes, ideal for sharing or a solo indulgence.

In summary, Sweet Creams Cafe shines through its dedication to fresh ingredients, vibrant flavors, and outstanding desserts. Its balance of savory dishes and sweet treats, paired with thoughtful service and an inviting ambiance, makes it a must-visit for food enthusiasts seeking both comfort and culinary delight in Stroudsburg.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards